Friday, June 25, 2010

To Kill a Classic

by Rachel

I read To Kill A Mockingbird twice as a high school student—once as an eleventh-grader in Australia, and then again the following year as a senior in the States. I was going to take an American literature course in college which examined the story further, but decided against it; I worried re-reading and overanalyzing the text would ruin the book for me. After reading it a couple of times and liking it, I’m thinking of taking it on once again this summer—as a reader this time, not as an overly analytical student.

Part of my decision to read To Kill A Mockingbird again comes from wanting to prove Allen Barra wrong, after reading his Wall Street Journal article. In this piece, Barra tells his readers that it’s time to “stop pretending that 'To Kill a Mockingbird' is some kind of timeless classic that ranks with the great works of American literature.” He believes there’s no ambiguity in the text of the book; that its “bloodless liberal humanism” is dated, and declares Flannery O’Conner’s writing a far worthier subject for high-school readers.

Allen Barra may complain of the book lacking ambiguity, but I’ve got to admit how much I enjoyed this book—twice. Combining controversial and eye-opening themes of injustice, courage and innocence, with Harper Lee’s simple and elegant narrative style, I think To Kill A Mockingbird is an incredibly relevant piece of literature that I hope will continue to be read in schools for years to come.

Do you think To Kill A Mockingbird is worthy of praise? Or, do you think it’s time to give students something else to read? If you agree with Allen Barra’s thoughts on the book, what do you think should be next on the curriculum for high school kids to read?

23 comments:

  1. I do love To Kill a Mockingbird and it's worthy of all the praise it gets BUT I do feel that curriculum probably need updating. There are plenty of excellent contemporary novels but school books are still stuck in the past. Granted I'm not from America but the most modern novel I studied at my school in Ireland was The Outsiders ('67), the most modern poet was Sylvia Plath (60's) and the most modern play was Juno and the Paycock (1924!). I'm not saying these don't still have merit but if you want young people especially the ones who AREN'T readers to engage then we need to update our offerings and there is plenty to choose from!

    ReplyDelete
  2. One of the most delightful parts of the 2009-10 school year for me was watching my 15-year-old daughter read TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD for the first time. Expertly drawn characters, great prose, and yes, subtlety--in Scout's observations and childlike voice--all make it a must-read. With a pub date of 1962, it's hardly "dated"! It truly qualifies as American literature, regional and lovely in its depiction of a community. Also: Without Atticus Finch, readers will be hard pressed to find a redeemable father figure in Southern lit.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love this book, it's a classic.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Did this guy Barra really get paid to write an article saying a book written over 50 years ago is dated?
    Of course its dated. Time is a one way street. Things change. Things move on. If Mockingbird were written today as a contemporary work then come next centaury someone else might pretend to be intellectual and collect a nice wage packet for saying its dated. The question is does a reader want to visit story of its own time? The answer from this reader is yes.

    The fact that Mockingbird is still talked about and the fact that Barra can get paid to talk about it, is a proof that it is a classic. In a hundred years time Mockingbird will still be talked about and read, while Stigg Larsson will have been pulped for toilet tissue and forgotten. (sorry, just had to have another bash at my least favourite author)

    ReplyDelete
  5. He believes there’s no ambiguity in the text of the book >>

    Standing up for what you believe in (and fighting for what you know is right) and LOSING lacks ambiguity?? Eh, what?

    ReplyDelete
  6. To Kill A Mockingbird is one of my all-time favorite books. I read it in high school, and revisited it again a few years ago on my own. The themes it explores are as relevant today as they were then, and the characters are vivid and engaging. It speaks to me every time I read it. If it's not on the curriculum when my daughter gets to high school, she will read it at home.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Perhaps the important part today of "Mockingbird" is not the language but the theme. Does it not remain important to remember, or to learn, how it was in the South? (I don't live there now, but did live in Virginia.) Is the courage to go against the stream not a timeless feature in novels?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I definitely think this is an extremely praise-worthy book that holds lessons just as relevant today as when it was first published. My only concern would be what else accompanies the curriculum. The voice of a white lawyer's child in the era is a valid voice and in this case beautifully written, but it is only one voice. In my nearly all-white high school, almost everything I ever read came from a white perspective. I would have gotten a tremendous amount of value from reading the perspectives of African-American characters as well.

    ReplyDelete

  9. I say many thanks to the father of the website admin I read this, because at this website I know a lot of information information that I did not know before his

    Obat Kanker Sumsum Tulang
    Obat Penyakit Kolera
    Penyakit Iritasi Lambung
    Obat Alami Kista Bartholin
    Obat Untuk Ibu Hamil

    ReplyDelete
  10. sampleassignment is the leading Australian assignment help provider hat offers complete University assessment services like contract law assignment, it assignment help, financial assignment help, project management assignment, literature review assignment help and more. Where most students lack time, subject-knowledge, and writing skills, Sample Assignment brings them highly qualified subject experts who can write their assignments for them at affordable rates or for those who looking for assignment maker. We have three teams who fully understand student problems and try to help them get over those problems.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thank you very much for such informative content. However, this is to inform the readers about nursing assignment help services. TutorVersal is one among those who offer Australian assignment help to university students. The firm came into existence in the year 2009 and since then it is known for its best assignment help. TutorVersal has been the preferred choice when it comes to assignment help in Australia and the rest of the countries. Also, they offer Free Samples so that you can clear your doubts and score A+ grades in your assignment. In order to reach us, we have issued a quick form and email to make our nursing assignment help more easily accessible.
    It helped me a lot so that I could complete my assignment effectively without taking help of any external assignment help in Australia. I appreciate your writing, I understand that to include all the information in a single content is impossible but the information you have given is appropriate as per my need.
    Nothing makes me happier than reading your excellent piece of writing.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This article gives the light in which we could see the reality. We are proud of our experts at Sample Assignment Best Online Australian assignment help. Their Dedication towards the assignment work and continuous support to Australian Students in their assignment and scoring HD grades. The students who avail professional  look for fast solutions. The fast essay writing service introduced by Sample assignment  by Online assignment Writer. Simply send in the details of your assignment, and the tam of sample assignment do the rest. Be it making a, how to write a report, paper, research paper or even a Clinical Reasoning Cycle research Report and Nursing Case study, we have you covered

    ReplyDelete
  13. Students are often required to prepare their nursing assignments based on the disease or disorder that prevails in the entire community. This is often seen as a challenging process by a majority of students. My Assignment Services provides online community care nursing assignment help, so that students can overcome their assessment writing problems easily. Our team of experts have written over a thousand nursing assignments in the past five years. Each assessment task submitted by us was done exactly per the marking rubric and guidelines provided by the student. With our online assignment help experts, students are able to score the top grades without any worries. We make sure that there is no late submission and the student receives their work right on time. For any case study related tasks, one can also avail of our case study assignment help service.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This information is really good. Thank you for this. Now, I would like to draw your attention towards a reliable assignment help firm named Online Assignment Expert. Working for more than 5 years in this firm has made me recommend them as the best Assignment Writing Help in Australia. This is because the experts here are not just confined to provide guidance on various academic subjects. They also provide students a lot of samples and reference assignments which prove to be really beneficial for them. Having delivered expert guidance in more than 50+ disciplines, our assignment makers are class apart. While delivering guidance to students, they make sure to put their firmest foot so that students excel in the particular subjects. They also never hesitate to cater to the urgent requirements of students. Be it a CDR, essay, dissertation, case study or even a CV, we efficiently deal with every assignment type. So, in case, you are in search of reliable assignment help experts, then Online Assignment Expert is the correct platform for you!

    ReplyDelete
  15. This blog is so informative. After reading this blog, I have actually come to know why students come up with queries such as “do my assignment for me” and more. It is all because they not only have shortage of time in their lives, but also because they lack some or other writing skills that are needed in solving such assignments.

    So, whenever I decide to pay someone to do assignment, I always rely upon My Assignment Services. This is because when you pay to do assignment, this firm always lives up to your expectations. They not only offer an extensive range of academic consultation services, but also offer you with a wide range of value-added services such as the live one-on-one session with the experts, free copy of the Turnitin report, free editing and proofreading services and many more.

    So, I always take my “do my assignment for me” queries to this firm.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Your blog is quite informative and creative at the same time. These are the two qualities especially help every content to become the most readable of all. However, these qualities are difficult to acquire which is the reason why students opt for assignment help services to get their queries solved within the time specified. My Assignment Services is widely preferred by students if they are looking for assignment Australia queries over the internet. We have more than 2000 professional experts who are available 24x7 to help you with all types of queries in giving you the assignment requirements and strictly adhering to the marking rubrics. My Assignment Services is a professional Australian assignment help service provider who has been expanding its services across the world. You can contact their experts by visiting their website at My Assignment Services if you come across any query related to any type of assignment and any subject

    ReplyDelete
  17. If you are looking for case study writing experts in Australia? Ph.D. assignment experts of Global Assignment Help Australia gives you quality solution for all Case Study help at an affordable price with 100% risk-free in all around the world.

    ReplyDelete


  18. When it comes to your academic dreams and grades we try to give our best by supporting you in completing your college assignments.
    Our administrative experts work dedicatedly and passionately to provide top quality essay writing help to the students. Meticulous paper structures,
    subject matter relevance, free from grammatical errors are main characteristics that our highly experienced and talented writers endeavor for.
    Still drowning in the worry to complete your college assignments?

    Assignment helpers Online


    ReplyDelete
  19. Opting Operations management as a career has been a popular choice in management students. Unique Submission endeavors to yield best assignment on operation management service to the students seeking to become operations manager. As completing academic assignments become tiresome for students they are in continuous search for help.

    Operations Assignment writing services


    ReplyDelete


  20. We at Indias Fastest News We try To provide the true side of the news, facts which are happening all over the globe

    IFN Website

    ReplyDelete
  21. If you want to stay updates with the latest technology related news we write different articles which includes Full Comparison | Specifications |Reviews. Do Check The website

    For All latest Technology related news

    ReplyDelete
  22. Get our dissertation help at affordable prices and make your academic venture more interesting by spending time exploring things that you love. We make sure to provide you brilliant content that you can submit to your college or university and grab grade marks for your overall success.

    ReplyDelete